buy 3ds max cheap purchase photoshop elements 7 windows 2003 enterprise license cost windows xp buy cheap windows 2008 datacenter cost buy adobe flash for mac download microsoft digital image suite 2006 microsoft word 2007 price corel draw 9 mac download photoshop for mac cheapest windows 7 ultimate microsoft money 2007 home & business microsoft project 2007 download microsoft mappoint europe 2004 download turbotax 2008 premier purchase vista upgrade autodesk mudbox 2010 download dreamweaver mac oem cs3 production premium mac windows datacenter licensing cheapest norton 360 3.0 where to buy ms office 2003 adobe audition buy adobe framemaker price purchase windows vista online download cubase 5 full buy streets & trips 2010 buy framemaker buy adobe photoshop for mac download font folio 11 adobe production premium mac buy autoroute 2007 buy adobe premiere cs4 windows 7 ultimate licensing buy powerpoint 2007 only windows 7 home premium cheapest price adobe illustrator cs4 sale windows datacenter 2008 licensing buy word 2007 online microsoft visio 2007 prices microsoft office 2008 discount buy office 2008 download buy visio 2002 buy windows 7 ultimate 64 bit purchase windows vista buy windows vista home premium 64 bit microsoft windows vista ultimate with sp2 (32bit) buy microsoft office 2003 download buy autodesk inventor 2008 windows 7 ultimate 64 bit iso windows vista home basic system requirements download adobe after effects cs3 purchase quickbooks buy windows 7 pro 64 download corel draw 10 buy microsoft windows 7 home premium buy autocad lt purchase windows vista ultimate key adobe cs4 fireworks download buy captivate navisworks price buy windows 7 license online windows 7 64 bit discount purchase windows 7 business cheap windows 7 ultimate download adobe dreamweaver sale symantec pcanywhere download corel software for mac download soundbooth cs4 norton 360 price comparison how much does windows 7 professional cost cheap windows 7 professional corel for mac download windows 7 cost too much corel draw mac version buy windows 7 pro 64 bit buy autocad electrical cheap windows 7 home premium best buy how much does microsoft works cost microsoft office 2003 pro oem windows 7 ultimate sale price autodesk mechanical desktop 2009 download buy windows 7 license adobe premiere pro cs4 cheap buy vista home premium oem download microsoft office 2003 professional edition buy autocad architecture 2010 framemaker price buy windows vista ultimate cheap microsoft works 9 price quickbooks enterprise 9.0 download buy illustrator for mac buy adobe photoshop cs3 cheap buy microsoft outlook 2007 only buy lightroom 2 buy maya 2009 unlimited download quickbooks premier 2007 buy flash cs3 pcanywhere buy adobe contribute mac download buy adobe after effects cs3 autocad electrical pricing download adobe soundbooth cs4 buy windows 7 64 bit oem turbotax pricing download adobe fireworks cs4 buy visual studio 2003 symantec norton 360 download excel 2003 price buy windows 7 home premium full buy adobe acrobat 9 pro extended buy wordperfect 11 buy windows 7 home premium retail buy inventor 2009 adobe creative suite 4 web premium download buy autocad architecture windows 7 ultimate 64 bit price buy windows 7 student windows 7 professional price uk microsoft office 2003 best buy purchase corel draw buy autocad 2010 lt buy visual studio 2008 license purchase windows 7 ultimate key where to buy microsoft frontpage download adobe after effects cs4 mac microsoft windows 7 professional 64-bit oem cs4 master collection download purchase windows 7 starter download adobe illustrator cs2 buy windows 7 home premium 64 bit microsoft digital image suite 2006 editor buy norton 360 v3 buy windows 7 ultimate cd key 3ds max sale download autodesk inventor 2009 autodesk maya 2009 price buy windows xp sp3 professional adobe contribute cs3 download get adobe premiere pro cs3 cheapest windows 7 ultimate oem adobe pagemaker cost mappoint 2006 download ms visio 2007 price autocad electrical oem autodesk architecture 2009 buy onenote 2007 autocad electrical 2008 download buy microsoft money 2007 buy photoshop lightroom 2 buy quicken 2010 premier where to buy streets and trips 2010 buy ms access 2003 autodesk 3ds max design price download microsoft project 2003 autosketch 9 download cheap windows vista ultimate download cs4 dreamweaver buy onenote online buy word 2007 download adobe suite cs3 price buy maya 2010 adobe dreamweaver cs4 discount buy microsoft office 2003 student ms works download autodesk 3ds max 2010 system requirements buy adobe premiere pro cs4 adobe cs4 web premium for mac microsoft streets and trips 2009 download microsoft word 2003 download full version adobe photoshop cs4 extended mac download buy presenter download indesign for mac download adobe creative suite 4 master collection buy adobe photoshop elements quicken 2010 pricing windows 2003 datacenter pricing cheap powerpoint software adobe illustrator mac download norton ghost 12 activation key windows 7 pro 64 bit oem buy access 2007 online steinberg nuendo download adobe premiere pro cs3 torrent buy adobe captivate 3 buy windows xp license online download wavelab buy autocad architecture 2009 purchase windows 7 key windows 7 ultimate buy online adobe illustrator cs2 download painter x for mac adobe creative suite 4 master collection download windows 7 home premium sale buy photoshop cs3 cheap buy pagemaker software windows 7 buy license cubase 4 cost after effects demo buy microsoft sql server 2008 download illustrator for mac buy adobe illustrator cs4 where can i buy cubase sx3 download adobe after effects mac buy adobe cs4 mac autocad 3ds max 2009 adobe premiere pro cs4 download buy excel 2003 online buy premiere pro cs3 microsoft word 2007 product key buy ms office 2003 pro buy windows 7 professional 64 bit oem microsoft excel 2003 buy buy windows xp with sp2 download corel painter for mac buy visual studio 2008 standard microsoft windows 7 ultimate cheap buy windows xp with service pack 2 cheap adobe photoshop cs4 cheap windows 7 ultimate retail windows vista business 64 bit iso buy windows 7 home premium cheap autodesk lustre 2010 price autodesk autosketch price adobe soundbooth cs4 download adobe after effects mac download windows datacenter license cost framemaker download adobe cs4 mac price windows 2003 datacenter edition adobe indesign cs3 cheap buy microsoft project 2000 buy microsoft office product key autocad inventor lt suite 2010 buy cubase sx3 buy windows 7 oem cheap buy photoshop cs4 download download autocad electrical corel video studio 12 download adobe indesign cs2 download download autodesk autosketch 10 adobe indesign cs4 windows full version cheap windows xp os cheap windows 7 ultimate key adobe contribute cs4 mac price windows 7 ultimate purchase buy visio 2000 adobe pagemaker price buy office onenote 2007 adobe illustrator cs3 direct download download streets and trips 2009 download adobe illustrator cs4 buy autocad cheap buy vista get windows 7 ms streets and trips 2008 download buy cheap dreamweaver cs4 windows 7 ultimate pricing microsoft frontpage sale buy photoshop elements 8 download quicken 2008 download adobe flash cs3 professional buy windows xp product key microsoft works download buy windows 7 ultimate key windows 7 costs buy adobe premiere pro for mac buy autosketch 9 buy microsoft access 2003 download price windows 7 ultimate windows vista cheapest price buy office 2003 windows 7 pro 64 bit download buy photoshop cs3 windows 2008 standard r2 how to buy microsoft frontpage buy mappoint 2006 corel draw x4 download autodesk lustre pricing cs3 design premium trial adobe robohelp 8 download how to buy powerpoint 2007 buy sql server 2008 enterprise windows 7 pro cheapest price cheap quickbooks software adobe indesign for mac download autosketch 10 buy autocad mechanical 2009 windows xp best price buy visual studio 2008 buy expression studio 3 buy quicken 2010 deluxe windows 7 pro sale purchase vista online cheap access 2007 microsoft visio download buy adobe illustrator student turbotax premier 2008 download windows 2008 server purchase buy symantec ghost cubase 5 buy online buy after effects cs4 mac buy sql server 2008 standard buy microsoft word 2007 download windows vista ultimate best buy adobe cs4 for mac buy powerpoint 2003 online buy microsoft word 2003 download download adobe dreamweaver cs3 corel draw x4 discount cheap acrobat 9 buy vista premium download wavelab 6 how to get photoshop for cheap windows 7 ultimate 64 bit best price after effects mac demo buy quicken software pcanywhere pricing quickbooks enterprise 9.0 price corel draw prices purchase microsoft office 2003 professional disable norton 360 buy windows 7 professional key microsoft office 2003 best price windows xp cheap price buy sql server 2008 enterprise edition ms office enterprise 2007 price autodesk 3ds max design 2010 download buy photoshop cs4 extended buy adobe contribute mac download cs3 design premium download adobe audition 3 full version turbotax deluxe 2009 price autocad 2010 system requirements buy wavelab cheap indesign cs3 adobe cs4 design premium cheap microsoft encarta premium 2009 dvd dreamweaver mac cs4 buy cubase 5 dongle buy sql server 2008 buy windows xp professional adobe acrobat prices buy quickbooks pro 2010 cheapest place to buy turbotax 2009 3ds max pricing buy acrobat professional 9 buy quickbooks pro 2009 adobe contribute trial buy powerpoint download vista business cheap windows 7 pro cheapest

Inexplicable?

December 13, 2009 · 13 comments

The Ottawa Citizen published an article today comparing the myriad (read: three) variations of A Christmas Carol currently available to Ottawa audiences.  The comparison was light-hearted and fun — as any article that differentiates productions based on their use of fart jokes should be — but Citizen Arts Editor Peter Simpson made a comment or two about our version that got me to thinking.

Re: the NAC production, he wrote “scenes and characters are reinvented, sometimes inexplicably”. He goes on to ask “what’s with the Rasta?” and notes that he “kept expecting [the Ghost of Christmas Present] to take a bong hit from his smoking horn of plenty”.  I can state unequivocally that no scenes in our adaptation are invented or reinvented — they’re all straight from the novel, with the exception of one small tweak to the character of the Ghost of Christmas Past — so I can only conclude that Mr Simpson is basing his first statement on the decision to cast the Ghost of Christmas Present using a black actor.

I was annoyed, at first, but have moderated my view, because this is a golden opportunity to point out something amazing and terrific about the NAC’s new resident acting company: it’s pretty fecking diverse.  We have two black people, two mixed-race Japanese, one Métis, one Indian, several rampant homosexuals, two bisexuals, and one person with Down syndrome.  For Christmas Carol, we also have three children.  Fully one-third of the company members are visible minorities.  This is how a Canadian national theatre company should look.

A quiet battle on the issue of diversity has been raging on the Canadian theatre scene for many years now.  One notable and important debate arose from an open letter Andrew Moodie wrote to the Shaw Festival’s artistic director, Jackie Maxwell, in 2008.  There is no question that the face of theatre produced in this country still does not reflect the face of the population, and the debate over color-blind casting and representation of diversity on stage rages on.  This much is irrefutable, though: the 2006 census reports that a little more than 20% of Canadian citizens are foreign-born, and that more than 20% of Ottawa’s population are visible minorities. By 2017, 19-23% of ALL Canadians will be visible minorities.

Compare this statistic with a sampling of the current state of diversity on stage in Ottawa.  The Gladstone Theatre is running a play with a cast of five; admirably the production is almost entirely female (I’m not touching on gender inequality in this post; it IS a problem as well, and the NAC company can fairly be criticized on this point), but it’s completely white.  Ottawa Little Theatre is running a musical with a cast of four: all white. Review the past several months or even years of theatre in this city, and you see a cavalcade of glorious, pale whiteness.  I’m not picking on specific companies, here: it’s not just these examples, and it’s not just an Ottawa problem.

So: if theatre should reflect the community in which it is situated (and it should, oh reader; most vehemently I say it should!), where does Ottawa’s 20% non-white population — that’s 200,000 people, as a rough estimate — go to see themselves?  Where do the other 800,000 local residents go to see work that reflects the reality of the people in the streets around them?

I have an answer to that question. Obviously.

Charles Dickens never specified the race of any of the characters in his seminal novel; that leaves an awful lot open to interpretation, and in a pitch to stay relevant and engaged with our community, we have fiercely and proudly seized the opportunity to explore possibilities.  It’ll happen again next month, when we stage Mother Courage and Her Children (and unlike Christmas Carol, I’m quite sure we have the only cart-pulling war-profiteer play running in Ottawa in January).  Indeed, the question we should be asking ourselves more regularly, as theatre practitioners, is why we always assume characters should be white unless told otherwise.

I understand Peter Simpson’s choice of word.  To an upper-middle-class, middle-aged white man, embracing diversity in this way may feel inexplicable.  It may be foreign to him — pardon the pun — but I obviously can’t speak for him and the broad range of his life experience.  I understand that kind of discomfort, though, because I feel the same way about straight people.  However, I do think he went with the wrong word in his article.

The forward-thinking, visionary choice to explore the possibility of a non-white Ghost of Christmas past is not inexplicable; it’s inevitable.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Technorati
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks

9 Tweets

{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }

Nik Maack December 13, 2009 at 10:32 am

Well said.

I found the choice of a rasta ghost of Christmas present worked extremely well. I didn’t find it in the least jarring. It worked. A big, beautiful, bountiful black man, booming and joyful, larger than life – isn’t that exactly the feeling the ghost of Christmas present gives off in the book and various film versions of the story? (It also convinced me of the obvious truth that Santa Claus is a black man.)

As long as an actor can play the part well, should race, gender, or sexual preference matter at all?

Jessica Ruano December 13, 2009 at 10:50 am

Oh wow. See, reading that article, I really did picture a Jamaican guy with dreadlocks smoking a bong. I think I missed the “kept expecting” part, as many people will. How terrifically misleading. Thanks for clearing that up, Kris.

And yes, having black people onstage is completely unheard of. What was the NAC thinking? No wonder the mainstream media is making a huge fuss over it. Honestly.

Nadine December 14, 2009 at 11:22 pm

As an actor and a visible minority, it’s no surprise I’m an advocate of ethnic diversity on stage. As you point out, our country has a mix of socio-cultural heritage…something that I agree should be reflected in our theatre (and the arts in general). I don’t believe this is a challenging concept…even for a white, upper-middle-income, middle-aged male.

I don’t necessarily believe multicultural casting is visionary. I do believe the opposite is culturally retarded.

Trekkie Monster December 15, 2009 at 6:58 pm

Hmm… Not having seen the OLD production of ILYYPNC perhaps I’m not qualified to comment, but weren’t there two earlier productions in Ottawa with similarly (un)pigmented casts?

Glass houses?

krisjoseph December 15, 2009 at 7:41 pm

No — no glass houses at all! You’ve completely missed the point. The post is a reaction to the perception that an African Ghost of Christmas Past is inexplicable.

I’m not trying to cast negative light on Ottawa companies for casting white. Both OLT and the Gladstone will — I know for a FACT — cast openly, based on who auditions. And Zucchini Grotto has, since 2004, put a commitment to diversity statement into every audition notice. Local companies must cast based on who comes out to the audition. The NAC is in a different boat; has the mandate and scope to cast its net nationally, and has committed to creating an acting company that reflects the face of the country — they have the resources to do that, and so they should. And it should NOT be inexplicable to see a black Ghost or a half-Japanese Mrs Cratchit on an Ottawa stage. That’s all I’m saying.

Trekkie Monster December 17, 2009 at 1:15 am

Points taken I guess (1) I rarely read Citizen reviews except for comic relief and (2) to me, casting diversity gives so much more to the production that it’s a no-brainer.

It we wanted the same bland stuff all the time we could just go to (insert favourite target for complaints about a lack of innovation here).

Leave a Comment

Additional comments powered by BackType

Previous post:

Next post: